sokol novák tdpA

Articles

  • People
  • Specialization
  • About
  • News
  • Articles
  • Careers
  • Contact
  • Česky
×

Non-applicability of the statute of limitations to a claim for the removal of defects in the declaration of the owner

by Mgr. Matěj Baloun
Published:
12. 10. 2026

In a recent judgment, Case No. 26 Cdo 315/2026, dated 22 July 2026, the Supreme Court addressed the issue of whether a claim for the removal of defects in the declaration of the owner is subject to the statute of limitations, concluding that the claim in question is not subject to limitation. It thus rejected the conclusions of the lower courts, which had assessed the claim for correction of the declaration as time-barred within the general three-year limitation period. According to the Supreme Court, the declaration of the owner has a proprietary nature and its defects may seriously interfere with ownership rights. In doing so, it opened the way for owners of (housing) units to remedy even long-standing errors in the declaration, without being restricted by the limitation period.

Introduction

The declaration of the owner is one of the basic institutes of condominium co-ownership. In practice, at the same time, it represents the most frequent means by which a (housing) unit comes into existence.[1] It is precisely by this instrument that the immovable property, most commonly a plot of land of which an apartment building forms part, is divided into (housing) units and common parts of the apartment building.[2] The regulation of the declaration in terms of its mandatory particulars and other aspects is contained in the provisions of section 1166 et seq. of Act No. 89/2012 Coll., the Civil Code, as amended (the “CC”).

In practice, however, it is not uncommon for substantive errors to occur in the declaration, which may consist, for example, in an inaccurate description of (housing) units or in the complete omission of one of them. The question of how, and in particular within what time frame, such defects may be remedied is of entirely fundamental practical importance for owners.

In its relatively “recent” judgment dated 22 July 2026, Case No.
26 Cdo 315/2026, the Supreme Court commented on the hitherto not expressly resolved question whether a claim for the removal of defects in the declaration of the owner pursuant to section 1168 CC is subject to the statute of limitations. Its conclusion that such a claim is not subject to limitation has fundamental consequences for the practice of communities of unit owners as well as individual owners.

Factual background of the case

On 22 December 1998, a declaration of the owner was drawn up, defining the individual flats and non-residential premises, the common parts of the building and the co-ownership shares. The declaration was registered in the land register with legal effects as of 6 April 1999. By this declaration, (housing) units in the building were defined pursuant to the then-effective Act No. 72/1994 Coll., on Ownership of Flats. However, the declaration contained an error consisting in the fact that among the defined (housing) units there also appeared unit No. 1004/105, designated as non-residential premises on the 5th floor. According to the plaintiff, this space had in fact never existed as a separate (housing) unit and had always constituted a common attic, that is, a common part of the building.

For the purpose of remedying this error, the individual owners of the (housing) units gradually signed, in the years from 2004 to 2018, an instrument concerning an amendment to the declaration of the owner, which was registered in the land register with legal effects as of 11 June 2018. However, in the course of this amendment, a further and this time more serious error occurred. Not only the non-existent unit No. 1004/105 was mistakenly omitted from the declaration, but also unit No. 1004/104, non-residential premises (a studio) on the 5th floor of the building, which actually existed and had throughout been in the plaintiff's exclusive ownership. As a consequence of the amended declaration, this studio formally became a common part of the building. The plaintiff maintained that his ownership right to the (housing) unit could not have ceased by a mere administrative error in the deed.

Decisions of the lower courts

The Municipal Court in Prague, as the court of the first instance, by judgment dated 15 March 2024 dismissed both the lawsuit for the removal of defects in the declaration of the owner and the lawsuit for a declaration of the plaintiff's ownership right to the (housing) unit, stating that the claim for the removal of defects in the declaration of the owner is subject to the general three-year limitation period under section 629 par. 1 CC. The plaintiff learned of the conversion of his (housing) unit into a common part of the building no later than 30 October 2018, when the registration proceedings in the land register were concluded; however, he did not file the lawsuit until 16 June 2022, that is, more than one year after the expiry of the three-year limitation period.

The court of the first instance further noted that, even if the claim had not been time-barred, the lawsuit would not have been well-founded. The amendment to the declaration had in fact been initiated by the plaintiff himself in his capacity as the building manager, who, among other things, filed the application for registration in the land register, in which he expressly stated that both (housing) units were to be deleted (i.e. Nos. 1004/104 and 1004/105). Moreover, the floor plans were said to show that after the amendment there would be no separate (housing) units on the 5th above-ground floor.

By judgment dated 6 March 2025, the High Court in Prague upheld the decision of the court of the first instance on the merits. It agreed with the conclusion that the lawsuit had been filed after the expiry of the limitation period and that the claim for correction of defects in the declaration was therefore time-barred. It further inferred that if a (housing) unit is not entered in the land register and has not been re-defined, it is not possible successfully to seek a declaration of ownership right to a thing which, from a legal perspective, does not exist.

Proceedings before the Supreme Court

The plaintiff therefore lodged an appeal on points of law with the Supreme Court, formulating as the appeal issue precisely the question of whether a claim for the removal of defects in the declaration of the owner pursuant to section 1168 CC is subject to the statute of limitations. He argued that this was a question which had not yet been expressly resolved in the decision-making practice of the Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court found the appeal on points of law admissible and, having reviewed the contested decision, concluded that it was well-founded. It set aside the judgment of the appellate court and remitted the case to it for further proceedings.

Reasoning of the Supreme Court

At the core of the Supreme Court's legal assessment was its consideration of the nature of the declaration of the owner and the consequences flowing from it for the question of limitation.

The Supreme Court proceeded from the provisions of section 1166 CC, pursuant to which the declaration of the owner is a unilateral legal act by which the owner divides the building into (housing) units. It emphasised that the declaration is not intended to be a document whose significance is exhausted at the moment of registration in the land register; rather, it is to serve as a current record of the actual state of the immovable property throughout the duration of condominium co-ownership. According to the court, the declaration of the owner has a proprietary nature.

The court further referred to Section 1167 CC, which provides that once ownership right to the (housing) units has been entered in a public register and another person has acquired a proprietary right to the (housing) unit, the declaration may neither be declared invalid nor may it be determined that ownership right to the (housing) unit did not arise. This provision constitutes a significant limitation protecting the legal certainty of acquirers of (housing) units, while at the same time creating a need for an alternative mechanism for remedying defects.

That alternative mechanism is precisely the procedure under section 1168 CC, which makes it possible to remove defects by which the declaration defines a (housing) unit in an indeterminate or incorrect manner. In this regard, the Supreme Court expressly stated that a specific type of incorrectness within the meaning of this provision may also be regarded as a situation where a (housing) unit was not defined in the declaration at all, although it should have been so defined, which was precisely the case of the plaintiff's studio. A claim for the removal of defects in the declaration of the owner pursuant to section 1168 CC is therefore not subject to the statute of limitations.

Pursuant to section 611 CC, all proprietary rights are subject to the statute of limitations, save for cases provided for by law; other rights are subject to limitation if the law so provides. The Supreme Court inferred that, having regard to the proprietary nature of the declaration of the owner, the general logic of limitation does not apply to a claim for the removal of its defects.

The logical conclusion, therefore, is that if it were possible to remove defects in the declaration only within the limitation period, an absurd situation would arise in which section 1167 CC, on the one hand, prevents the declaration from being challenged for invalidity and section 1168 CC, on the other hand, provides a substitute mechanism of remedy, yet that mechanism would be time-limited. Certain incorrectnesses would thus remain entirely irremediable after the expiry of the limitation period, even though they may seriously interfere with the ownership rights of owners of (housing) units. According to the Supreme Court, such an interpretation would be contrary to the meaning and purpose of the legislation as a whole.

Importance of the decision for practice and conclusion

The commented decision of the Supreme Court is of fundamental importance for the practice of communities of unit owners, as well as for individual owners of flats and non-residential premises. Its practical implications may be summarised on several levels.

The three-year limitation period under section 629 par. 1 CC does not apply to a claim for the removal of defects in the declaration of the owner. This is crucial especially in cases where defects in the declaration have existed for many years without the owners being aware of them, or where the removal of defects is complicated by the need for the cooperation of a larger number of persons.

The decision further strengthens the protection of ownership right to (housing) units. As the case under consideration illustrates, a mere administrative error in the declaration may result in the formal “extinction” of a (housing) unit and its conversion into a common part of the building. If a claim for correction of the declaration were subject to limitation, an owner could lose the protection of his right even where the error occurred without any fault on his part.

The Supreme Court further expressly stated that, as incorrectness within the meaning of section 1168 CC, even the complete omission of a (housing) unit from the declaration may be regarded. In doing so, it extended the scope of application of this provision beyond mere inaccuracies in the description of existing (housing) units.

The said decision may therefore be regarded as beneficial for the practice of communities of unit owners.

[1] ŠUSTROVÁ, Daniela. a) Declaration of the owner. In: ŠUSTROVÁ, Daniela. The Land Register from the Perspective of Practice and Case Law. 1st edition. Praha: C. H. Beck, 2023, p. 83.

[2] Ibid.

Source: epravo.cz

sokol novák tdpA
law office
  • Česky
  • People
  • Specialization
  • Careers
  • About
  • News
  • Articles
  • Contact
  • Online consulting
  • Client zone
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook

A company registered in the Business Register held by the Municipal Court in Prague, file no. C 187692.

  • Cookies and privacy policy
  • Terms and conditions
  • Information for whistleblowers